"I am, and this is how I will run the country [after being recognized in a thrift store and asked if she was running for VP]] " - Winona LaDuke
 

ADVERTISMENTS:





call us:
206-350-1082

support killoggs!
  Mon

chrisx



Killoggs Debating Techniques


Conversational Terrorism
All of the techniques listed in this document have actually been witnessed, told to us by someone else, or dreamed up. They are described in first person for clarity of motive.
The intent of detailing and naming these insidious tactics is so that the reader may AVOID USING THEM, to quickly recognize if someone else is using them, and for fun. There is much humor in the way people (consciously or unconsciously) conversationally cheat.
It is hoped that exposing these tactics will help muzzle the growing abuse in our conversational landscape. Give copies to both perpetrators and victims (only NOT for profit use).
The examples are overblown in an attempt to be both clear and funny. Use your imagination to think of how you (perish the thought) and others have used these techniques in the past.
They have been grouped by major category, with the best (worst!) saved for last.

First, we have the Ad Hominem Variants where you attack the person as a way to avoid truth, science, or logic which might otherwise prove you wrong. Next are the Sleight of Mind Fallacies, which act as "mental magic" to make sure the unwanted subject disappears. Then, we move on to Delay Tactics, which are subtle means to buy time when put on the spot. Then, the ever popular Question as Opportunity ploys, where any question can be deftly averted. Finally, we have the Cheap Shot Tactics and Irritants, which are basically "below the belt" punches.

Ad Hominem Variants

OVER YOUR HEAD:

"I'd like to respond to that, but taking into account your background, education, and intelligence, I am quite sure that you would not be able to understand."

EVEN YOU:

"My next point will be so cogent that even you will be able to understand it."

"Even you should be able to grasp the next point."

YOU'LL GET OVER IT:

"I used to think that way when I was your age."

"As you mature emotionally (or mentally, or spiritually), you will grow out of your present way of thinking, and you will eventually come around to my point of view."

"You're new here, aren't you?"

WISHFUL THINKING:
Instead of proving a point true or false, this technique tries to imply that the individual's desires have led him/her astray without dealing with the merits of the issue itself. (C.S. Lewis termed this "Bulverism".) Any strong desire can be shown to have tainted a conclusion or clouded objectivity, which casts doubt on the legitimacy of a point. This is very close to the classic ad hominem fallacy: "you say that because you are a man."

"You support capital punishment because of a deep-rooted death wish common among those who have suffered emotional traumas during childhood."

"You oppose capital punishment because of an irrational suppressed death taboo common among those who have suffered emotional trauma during childhood."

"You weren't breast fed as a child, were you?"

MORE INSIDE-------

[ posted by chrisx at 02/20/2006 05:52:08 PM ]
[ trackback ]


joe




The inner workings out

So, for some reason, the people at my jobsite CAN'T NOT shit on the back of the port-o-john seat. I'll be posting my entire collection of pics here later, but for now- how did this get here?

[ posted by joe at 02/20/2006 11:01:52 PM ]
[ trackback ]


Daily Summary for 2006/02/20:
Journals:
posted a journal entry at 02/20/2006 04:06 AM
posted a journal entry at 02/20/2006 04:49 AM
posted a journal entry at 02/20/2006 01:25 PM
posted a journal entry at 02/20/2006 10:13 PM
posted a journal entry at 02/20/2006 11:07 PM
In the News:
Scooters becoming popular transportation 02/20/2006 4:36 pm
More Than 1,000 Protest Cartoon Depiction of Prophet 02/20/2006 8:22 pm
Links:
Katsucon, Washington D.C., 2006 02/20/2006 05:17 am
The Myth of the 02/20/2006 04:48 pm
Sounds:
Jumpers (Video) by Sleater-Kinney 02/20/2006 3:13 pm
Daily Photo:
No Daily Photo on this day.
Daily Comic:
No Daily Comic on this day.
Killoggs Birthdays on this day:
None.

Response History for this day.

Recent Responses

500 Most Common Passwords
09:54 by myriam +1

2009 is my year and no one can take it from me
05:41 by meredith

500 Most Common Passwords
04:00 by rick

XXVIII
03:56 by rick

And it's hard to say you don't...
03:32 by brandon +3



[ last 24 hours ]


Active Posts

the rot in my belly (14)

landscapes & portraits. (8)

2009 is my year and no one can take it from me (1)

I have internet access again (1)

Dubya and the Pirates (1)



Sticky Posts

Xboxin' (48)

who still lives in louisiana? (29)

LSU Alumni Crawfish Boils (6)

guys lets go get crabs soon! (19)



In the news

The Polaroid camera is back, in digital

Karl Lagerfeld defends fur industry saying 'beasts' would kill us if we didn't kill them

Obama Moves to Counter China in Space With Pentagon-NASA Link

Bristol Palin could earn $300,000 for baby pics

why i like clint eastwood

Shoe Hurled at Bush Flies Off Turkish Maker’s Shelves

1950s pinup model Bettie Page dies in LA at 85

UN Blowback: More Than 650 International Scientists Dissent Over Man-Made Global Warming Claims

[ view all news ]


Updated Journals









[ view journals ]


Public Calendar

[ all events ]


Interesting Links

500 Most Common Passwords
kind of a big deal
Killoggs Weed Krispies :[
Have a Thermodynamically Consistent Christmas
Squidtivity
Charity Porn
Burger King FLAME cologne
Jello Biafra's Open Letter to Barack Obama
[ view all ]


Random Image



Sounds

The Hand of the Almighty by John R. Butler

I Made a Resolution by Sea Wolf

Ladies and Gentlemen by Saliva

Rock Bottom by Sweet Crude Bill and the Lighthouse Nautical Society

Little Red Rhumbahood by Sam Ulano

Elegy (Crystal Glass) by Zoe Mulford

You Are the Generation That Bought More Shoes... by Johnny Boy

Spider's House by Califone

[ all sounds ]


Member Login


Nickname:

Password:




Search Killoggs


old style search


Less Recent Posts

It snowed 2 inches last night
by brandon [13]

Best
by katie [3]

halp!
by angie [14]

American folk music legend Odetta dies at 77
by chuck [3]

Now that
by brandon [12]

I'm surprised you don't have Killoggs scripted
by anthony [12]

Sale thru Xmas
by chrisx [6]

Happy Thanksgiving!
by meredith [25]

Even Josh Couldn't See This Coming
by art [19]

TOMORROW
by chrisx [3]

B-More & Dee See Killoggers
by reggie [12]

albums you've listened to in the last week
by brandon [15]

ullanbaatar
by anotherben [18]

Listening to the fireworks from Grant Park...
by meredith [15]

I'm going to go out on a limb...
by brandon [122]

Stuff I Like
by reggie [7]

How Swede It Is
by reggie [24]

How Swede It Is
by reggie [0]

Vote Early, Vote Often!
by myriam [14]

animation party tomorrow
by jenny [1]

[ # ] = responses

[ view archives ]


Link to Us

killoggs weblog
[ more ]


Stats

2 posts, 0 responses on this page













rest in peace

© 2000-2005 : Josh (code/design); Ben (drawings); the Writers.
Policies & Privacy Statement - Call or Fax Killoggs at 206-350-1082